Friday, December 19

core strength or motor development is not must for speech and communication Dr Kondekar

Why core muscle strength is NOT required for development of speech and communication

1. Speech is a neuro-cognitive function, not a gross motor task

Speech and communication are primarily controlled by:

Auditory cortex (listening & sound discrimination)

Language centers (Wernicke’s & Broca’s areas)

Fine oral motor coordination (lips, tongue, jaw)

Cognitive intent & social motivation

👉 Core muscles (abdomen, back, trunk) are not part of the speech motor pathway.

2. Children speak while lying, sitting, crawling, or being carried

Children:

Babble while lying on their back

Speak while sitting supported

Talk while being carried

Communicate even in wheelchairs or beds


👉 If core strength were essential, speech would stop in non-upright positions, which never happens.

3. Speech precedes mature core strength development

Developmental timelines show:

Babbling starts at 4–6 months

Meaningful words by 10–15 months

Sentences by 2–3 years


At these ages:

Core strength is immature

Postural stability is still developing


👉 Speech clearly emerges before strong core control, proving it is not dependent on it.

4. Children with severe motor disability still develop speech

Examples:

Children with cerebral palsy

Children with spinal cord involvement

Children with muscular dystrophy


Many have:

Poor trunk control

Weak core muscles


Yet:

Receptive language develops

Speech and communication can develop with appropriate auditory input


👉 This decisively disproves the “core strength → speech” myth.

5. What speech actually requires

Speech development needs:

1. Listening exposure (auditory nutrition)


2. Repetition of sound patterns


3. Meaningful language input


4. Motivation to communicate


5. Neural plasticity



🚫 None of these require abdominal or back muscle strengthening.
L

6. Confusion arises from posture ≠ prerequisite

Good posture can:

Improve breath support

Improve attention span

Reduce fatigue


But:

Helpful ≠ essential

Supportive ≠ prerequisite


👉 Posture may optimize speech, but does not create it.

7. Over-emphasis on core strength delays real intervention

When parents are told:

> “First build core, then speech will come”

They lose:
Crucial early language exposure time
Window of maximum brain plasticity
👉 This delay causes avoidable speech delay, not improvement.

Dr kondekars One-liners


1. Speech comes from the brain, not the belly.


2. Children talk even when lying down.


3. Listening builds language, not muscle power.


4. Core strength helps posture, not speech development.


5. Babbling starts before sitting — proof enough.


6. Speech delay cannot be fixed by physical exercises.


7. Language grows through ears, not abs.


8. Strong listening today prevents speech delay tomorrow.


9. Waiting for motor skills wastes brain plasticity.


10. Talk first, train muscles later if needed.

_______


> Speech comes from the brain through listening, not from the stomach muscles.

Final clinical conclusion
Core muscle strength is NOT a prerequisite for speech or communication development.
Speech is a brain-driven, listening-dependent, language process, and should be addressed directly, not postponed for motor milestones.


1. “Core Strength & Speech Development"
MYTH

> “Child must develop core muscle strength before speech can develop.”



✅ FACT

> Speech and communication develop from the brain and ears — not from abdominal or back muscles.
WHY THIS MYTH IS WRONG

Children talk while lying, sitting, or being carried

Babbling starts before strong trunk control

Children with poor core strength still understand and speak

Speech centers are in the brain, not in the trunk.

KEY MESSAGE BY DR KONDEKAR FOR PARENTS OF AUTISM KIDS
> 🧠 Speech is brain-driven.
👂 Listening builds talking.
💬 Communication does not wait for core muscles.


2. WHAT SPEECH ACTUALLY NEEDS

SPEECH DEVELOPS WITH:

✔ Continuous listening exposure
✔ Repetition of sound patterns
✔ Meaningful spoken language
✔ Emotional connection
✔ Neural plasticity

SPEECH DOES NOT NEED:

✘ Sit-ups
✘ Balance boards
✘ Core strengthening
✘ Waiting for posture milestones


---

STRONG LINE FOR PARENTS

> No amount of muscle exercise can replace daily spoken language exposure.----
___
DEVELOPMENTAL PROOF

NORMAL TIMELINE

4–6 months: Babbling

10–15 months: First words

2–3 years: Phrases & sentences


👉 At this age:

Core muscles are immature

Trunk stability is still developing


CONCLUSION

> Speech appears BEFORE strong core strength — therefore it is not dependent on it.
___
There is no neurodevelopmental evidence that core muscle strength is a prerequisite for speech or communication.
Speech is a cortical, auditory-linguistic function, and delaying language intervention for motor milestones leads to avoidable speech delay.

Build the brain with words — not the body with exercises — to develop speech.



No comments:

Post a Comment